Oh My! Pecan Pie

Sorry, this item is out of stock

We expect to be restocked by October 31st. Would you like us to notify you when this product is available?

Oh my! is exactly what you will say when you sink your teeth into quite possibly the most amazing pecan pie. EVER. We don't use tiny little pecans in this bad boy. We use our premium mammoth sized pecans. Guaranteed to have a mouthful of pecans in every single bite. Love the gooey sweet center of a pecan pie? Just wait until your taste buds get to the middle of this pie. Made by hand in small batches, we promise this is 8" pie is as good, if not better, than grandma's pecan pie.

This price includes special insulated packaging.

Note: We encourage you to ship this in 2 days or less to maintain freshness and appearance.

Instructions for enjoying this deliciousness:

1) Remove the pie from the silver insulated pouch that it is shipped in.

2) If you plan on eating this right away (we certainly recommend tasting this treat early and often) allow to sit at room temperature for 3-4 hours and then dig right in!

3) If you like your pie warm (and who doesn't?!?) you can reheat it in the oven at 350 degrees for a maximum of 10 minutes.

4) Don't be afraid to add a scoop of vanilla ice cream and whipped cream to complete this most amazingly perfect treat.

Storage Tips:

1) Your pie can stay fresh at room temperature for up to 2 weeks.

2) If you wish to freeze your pie, you definitely can. We recommend freezing it as soon as you receive it for up to 3 months in an air tight freezer bag.

Customer Reviews

Leave online feedback and share your thoughts with other customers!

“As usual, you nutty people sent my order on time and perfectly packaged. My "complaint" is that we already ate the delish pecan pie and guess what - it's gone. Amazing! I couldn't bake a better pecan pie. Sooooo good! Yum!”

November 13, 2010

“The pecan pie sample is the best pecan pie we ever tasted!”

, Norton, OH November 12, 2010

“Incredibly good products incredibly fast. Simple yet so many fall short. I don't know of a better business to deal with! Thank you!”

, Clay, NY November 10, 2010

“The pecan pie is to die for...I love it and your speedy delivery service is awesome..thanks”

, beachwood, nj November 10, 2010

“That pecan pie was beyond delicious!! The walnuts were also quite good. Thank you for the samples of the chocolate covered mint cookies, they are quite tasty also. Thank you so much.”

, Orlando, FL March 27, 2010

“We LOVE your Oh My Pecan Pie!!! Truly the best Pecan Pie we have ever tasted. The nuts are wonderful, the crust amazing, and the filling ridiculously good!! We hope Nuts Online will consider making it in a larger size in the future - it is so good!”

, New Orleans, LA February 24, 2010

“Never disappointed in the product or the delivery with you guys! With such a huge selection, I always find what I'm looking for. And that Oh My Pecan Pie? OH MY!!! So yummy. Thanks for making my holiday so tasty!”

, Philadelphia, PA December 11, 2009

“Love the dates. Can't wait to try the pecan pie. Your service is the best!!”

December 4, 2009

“Dear Nuts Online,
You have surpassed, once again, my expectations. I included an additional order of your snack bags and your veggie chips, luv, luv, luv them all! My friends at work are begging me to make another order and I am looking forward to it! Your products are healthy and good tasting. I am a customer for life! ”

, Jamaica, New York December 1, 2009

“TO:All Nut fans.
The Oh My Pecan Pie really should be called Oh My Nutty Pecan Pie is so good.The pie melts in your mouth. When you take a bite out of this nutty pecan pie all one can say is oh-my that's so good. It is more than a nut experience because the pecans used in the pie is whole pecans and you get at least 6-8 pecans in every bite.
This pie has taken the mystery out of the stressful holiday shopping. I want every teacher, friend and family members to experience the nutty pecan pie.
Ann (Somerset NJ ) ”

, somerset, nj November 27, 2009

“Got it. Haven't opened it yet--why didn't you remind me that I was out of organic raisins from the holidays--that's a joke.

I really wanted to mention that we ate the free pecan pie that you sent with an earlier order for Christmas. It was beyond wonderful. My husband doesn't usually like pecan pie and he said it was the best he ever had. Also, it was packed perfectly and kept just right since before Thanksgiving when I made pumpkin pie.

My experience is usually that such an offer is often disappointing. Not so here. You outdid yourself. Thank you and Happy New Year.”

, Ozona, Texas January 7, 2014


Pecans, light and dark corn syrup, plugra butter, light brown sugar, granulated sugar, eggs, vanilla paste, crust (wheat flour(unbleached, uninriched), palm oil, water, pure clover honey, sea salt.)

Packaged in the same facility as peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, and milk products.

Country of Origin: United States

ID: 4903

From our family to yours, since 1929

Our beloved grandfather, Poppy Sol, started this business in an open-air market. Three generations later, we’re still bringing smiles to our customers' faces.