Old Time Candy

Airheads

1 item

Anise Balls

1 item

Assorted Fruit Chews (Sugar Free)

1 item

Assorted Sixlets

1 item

Assorted Toffees

1 item

Assorted Toffees (Sugar Free)

1 item

Bit-O-Honey

1 item

Black Jack Taffy

1 item

Blow Pops

1 item

Boyer's Mallo Cups

1 item

Candy Blox

1 item

Candy Bonz

1 item

Candy Corn

1 item

Candy Necklaces (Wrapped)

1 item

Candy Peas & Carrots

1 item

Candy Pebbles

1 item

Candy Sticks

27 items

Caramel Creams

4 items

Caramels

1 item

Charleston Chew

1 item

Chewy Spree

1 item

Chick-O-Stick Bites

2 items

Chocolate Foil Sport Balls

1 item

Chocolate Sponge

2 items

Chocolate Stars

1 item

Cinnamon Imperials

1 item

Circus Peanuts

2 items

Clove Balls

1 item

Conversation Hearts

1 item

Cotton Candy

1 item

Cotton Candy Crunchers

1 item

Creme Drops

1 item

Dum-Dum Pops

1 item

Fruit Marzipan

1 item

Fudgie Rolls (Sugar Free)

1 item

Ginger Balls

1 item

Ginger Snaps

3 items

Goetze's Mini Cow Tales

1 item

Good & Plenty

1 item

Hershey Kisses

1 item

Hershey's Miniatures

1 item

Hershey's Nuggets Assortment

1 item

Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped)

1 item

Hot Tamales

1 item

Jelly Nougats

1 item

Laffy Taffy

1 item

M&M's

34 items

Maple Double Dip Peanuts

1 item

Marshmallow Coconut Toasties

1 item

Marshmallow Creme

1 item

Mary Janes

1 item

Milk Duds

1 item

Mini Toblerone

1 item

NECCO Banana Split Chews

1 item

NECCO Candy Buttons

1 item

Necco Wafers

1 item

Nerds

1 item

Nostalgic Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar

1 item

Nostalgic Hershey's Milk Chocolate with Almonds Bar

1 item

Now & Later

1 item

Old Fashioned Christmas Candy

1 item

Original Mike & Ike

1 item

Peanut Butter Bars

2 items

Peanut Chews

1 item

Peppermint Sticks

1 item

Pez Refill Packs

1 item

Pop Rocks

3 items

Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups

1 item

Reese's Pieces

1 item

Ring Pops

1 item

Rock Candy

18 items

Runts

1 item

Salt Water Taffy

10 items

Silly Yellow Bananas

1 item

Skittles

1 item

Smarties

1 item

Squirrel Nut Zippers

1 item

Starburst Fruit Chews

1 item

Swiss Petite Fruits

1 item

Tootsie Rolls

5 items

Turkish Taffy

4 items

Walnettos

1 item

Wax Bottles

1 item

1950's Retro Candy Box

1 item

1960's Retro Candy Box

1 item

1970's Retro Candy Box

1 item

1980's Retro Candy Box

1 item

Walk down memory lane with nostalgic old time candy, always a hit for a candy buffet. Old time candy is also a great wedding candy option or a special treat for classic movie night!

Our beloved grandfather, Poppy Sol, started this business in an open-air market. Three generations later, we’re still bringing smiles to our customers' faces.

Top sellers

Bit-O-Honey $3.99/lb

Salt Water Taffy $3.99/lb

Old Fashioned Christmas Candy $4.99/lb

Mini M&M's (Milk Chocolate) $6.99/lb

“AMAZING! That's worth saying twice.YOU GUYS ARE AMAZING!I just got my order of gummy bears&other assorted goodies! I haven't had the giant cinnamon bears since I was a kid-they were my favorite and I haven't found/seen them since. They taste like Heaven! Also,my husband nearly cried with joy when he saw the POUND bag of Mar-bits you had,so I got that too. He's the type to pick all the marshmallows out of the cereal,so I thank you for offering them! LOL! SUPER FAST SHIPPING&GREAT PRODUCTS! God bless you guys,I really adore your service! I'll be back soon! *hugs* Mandy”

— Mandy, Baltimore, Maryland March 24, 2010

See 1,170 related customer reviews