yellow candyRemove / wrappedRemove / weddingsRemove

  • Banana Salt Water Taffy Banana Salt Water Taffy

    Old fashioned salt water taffy in a great banana flavor.

    $4.99/lb
  • Butterscotch Candy Butterscotch Candy

    Hard butterscotch sucking candies.

    $2.99/lb
  • Mary Janes Mary Janes

    Mary Janes are made from the same recipe since 1914, these old time favorites are a chewy blend of molasses and peanut butter.

    $3.99/lb
  • NECCO Banana Split Chews NECCO Banana Split Chews

    Our tasty Banana Split Chews from NECCO are the perfect tasty treat.

    $3.99/lb

Narrow by tag

Sign up for our newsletter

Receive limited, email-only offers

Jeffrey's Picks

Samples

Samples

Want to try a smaller size before indulging big time? Check out our tasty samples! $2.50 a sample.