taffyRemove / chocolates & sweetsRemove / wedding candyRemove / old time candyRemove

  • Bit-O-Honey Bit-O-Honey

    A hard and chewy candy with almond bits blended into a hard honey flavored taffy. Bit-of-Honey is bite-sized, low-fat, and tasty!

    $3.99/lb
  • Salt Water Taffy Salt Water Taffy

    Old fashioned Salt Water Taffy in an array of colors and flavors. This brings back all of those summer Boardwalk memories.

    $3.99/lb
  • Mary Janes Mary Janes

    Mary Janes are made from the same recipe since 1914, these old time favorites are a chewy blend of molasses and peanut butter.

    $3.99/lb
  • Squirrel Nut Zippers Squirrel Nut Zippers

    Squirrel Nut Zippers are also known as nut chews. These great peanut chews are a classic.

    $4.49/lb
  • Salt Water Taffy (Sugar Free) Salt Water Taffy (Sugar Free)

    Old fashioned Salt Water Taffy in an array of colors and flavors. You will love our Taffy Lite Salt Water Taffy

    $7.99/lb
  • Starburst Fruit Chews Starburst Fruit Chews

    The classic chewy Starbursts. Loaded with flavor. They come in lemon, orange, strawberry, and cherry.

    $4.99/lb
  • Now & Later Now & Later

    Assorted flavors of Now and Later.

    $4.49/lb
  • Vanilla Turkish Taffy Vanilla Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Vanilla Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99
  • Banana Turkish Taffy Banana Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Banana Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99
  • Chocolate Turkish Taffy Chocolate Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Chocolate Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99
  • Strawberry Turkish Taffy Strawberry Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Strawberry Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99

Narrow by tag

Sign up for our newsletter

Receive limited, email-only offers

Jeffrey's Picks

Samples

Samples

Want to try a smaller size before indulging big time? Check out our tasty samples! $2.50 a sample.