kosherRemove / kosher dairyRemove / dark chocolateRemove / rainbow candyRemove

  • NY Espresso Mix NY Espresso Mix

    Not sure which flavored espresso bean you like? Try them all in our NY Espresso Mix, including dark chocolate, milk chocolate, cappuccino, twist, and then some!

    $9.49/lb
  • Dark Chocolate Peanut M&M's® Dark Chocolate Peanut M&M's®

    The unmistakable taste of Peanut M&M's now in dark chocolate! Guaranteed to melt in your mouth and not in your hands.

    $7.99/lb
  • Assorted Malted Milk Balls Assorted Malted Milk Balls

    Love malted milk balls but can't choose just one flavor? Sink your taste buds into this delicious assortment featuring milk, dark, ultimate, mint cookie, and pumpkin spice malted milk balls

    $8.49/lb
  • Dark Chocolate M&M's® Dark Chocolate M&M's®

    The unmistakable taste of M&M's® now in dark chocolate!

    $7.99/lb

Narrow by tag

Sign up for our newsletter

Receive limited, email-only offers

Jeffrey's Picks

Samples

Samples

Want to try a smaller size before indulging big time? Check out our tasty samples! $2.50 a sample.