chocolates & sweetsRemove / old time candyRemove

  • Jelly Belly Watermelon Jelly Belly Watermelon

    Enjoy the sweet unmistakable taste of watermelon flavored Jelly Belly jelly beans.

    $7.99/lb
  • Peppermint Candy Sticks Peppermint Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These peppermint candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Pretzel M&Ms Pretzel M&Ms

    A delicious pretzel ball surrounded by milk chocolate in a candy shell that melts in your mouth. These pretzel M&M's are a huge hit!

    $7.99/lb
  • Strawberry Pop Rocks Strawberry Pop Rocks

    Pour some strawberry pop rocks into your mouth and feel that unique popping on your tongue!

    $2.99
  • Tangerine Candy Sticks Tangerine Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These tangerine candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Black Whirly Pop (3 Inches) Black Whirly Pop (3 Inches)

    Black and white whirly pops are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These classic old time lollipops are a real treat. 1.5 ounces and 3" diameter.

    $4.99
  • Lemon Candy Sticks Lemon Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These lemon candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Brown M&M's Brown M&M's

    A favorite candy of many, these milk chocolate M&M's will melt in your mouth not in your hand! Perfect for wedding favors, candy buffets, or just snacking. These Brown M&M's are sure to please.

    $11.99/lb
  • Cotton Candy Crunchers Cotton Candy Crunchers

    Love the taste of cotton candy but don't want to deal with the mess? Try these cotton candy crunchers. Crunchy hard candy in cherry, lemon, and blue raspberry flavors. These have the similar texture and taste as Runts.

    $4.99/lb
  • Sour Apple Candy Sticks Sour Apple Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These sour apple candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Jelly Belly Jewel Berry Jelly Belly Jewel Berry

    These Jelly Belly jelly beans have a traditional berry flavor with a unique and beautiful aqua shimmer coating. Make these a part of your candy buffet to impress guests.

    $8.99/lb
  • Sassafras Candy Sticks Sassafras Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These sassafras candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Giant Gummy Bears Giant Gummy Bears

    Wow! All we can say is wow. We have never quite seen a gummy bear this BIG. This individual gigantic gummy bear stands in at over 3.5 inches tall and 2.5 inches wide. This individual gummy bear comes in assorted flavors such as blue raspberry, cherry, green apple, orange, and grape. Unfortunately, we can not honor individual color/flavor requests or guarantee that you will receive all flavors. We apologize for any inconvenience.

    $5.99
  • Watermelon Pop Rocks Watermelon Pop Rocks

    Pour some watermelon pop rocks into your mouth and feel that unique popping on your tongue!

    $2.99
  • Cinnamon Candy Sticks Cinnamon Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These cinnamon candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Jelly Belly A&W Root Beer Jelly Belly A&W Root Beer

    Jelly Belly jelly beans in the classic A&W Root Beer flavor.

    $7.99/lb
  • Anise Drops Anise Drops

    Anise drops are an old time sanded hard candy with that great anise flavor.

    $3.49/lb
  • Dark Green M&M's Dark Green M&M's

    A favorite candy of many, these milk chocolate M&M's will melt in your mouth not in your hand! Perfect for wedding favors, candy buffets, or just snacking. These Dark Green M&M's are sure to please.

    $11.99/lb
  • Licorice Candy Sticks Licorice Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These licorice candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Green Rock Candy Sticks (Unwrapped) Green Rock Candy Sticks (Unwrapped)

    This classic lime flavored rock candy comes in a package of 10 units on a stick. The sticks measure approximately 6 1/2 inches, and the rock candy measures approximately 4 inches. Great for wedding favors, candy buffets, or just to eat!

    $8.99
  • Mega Warheads Mega Warheads

    Mega Warheads are the ultimate sour treat. Detonate explosive sour flavor bombs inside your mouth!

    $7.99/lb
  • Maroon M&M's Maroon M&M's

    A favorite candy of many, these milk chocolate M&M's will melt in your mouth not in your hand! Perfect for wedding favors, candy buffets, or just snacking. These Maroon M&M's are sure to please.

    $11.99/lb
  • Rainbow Whirly Pop (5.25 inches) Rainbow Whirly Pop (5.25 inches)

    Rainbow whirly pops are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These classic old time lollipops are a real treat. 6 ounces and 5.25" diameter.

    $4.49
  • Blackberry Candy Sticks Blackberry Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These blackberry candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Bubble Gum Pop Rocks Bubble Gum Pop Rocks

    Pour some bubble gum pop rocks into your mouth and feel that unique popping on your tongue!

    $2.99
  • Red Whirly Pop (3 Inches) Red Whirly Pop (3 Inches)

    Red and white whirly pops are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These classic old time lollipops are a real treat. 1.5 ounces and 3" diameter.

    $4.99
  • Gummy Mustache Gummy Mustache

    Show off your 'stache with these fruity flavored gummy mustaches. Great for mustache-themed parties.

    $4.99/lb
  • Jelly Belly Jewel Bubble Gum Jelly Belly Jewel Bubble Gum

    These Jelly Belly jelly beans have a traditional bubble gum flavor with a unique and beautiful pastel pink shimmer coating. Make these a part of your candy buffet to impress guests.

    $8.99/lb
  • Orange Candy Sticks Orange Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These orange candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Peppermint Drops Peppermint Drops

    Sanded old time peppermint drops bring back great memories.

    $3.49/lb
  • Rock Candy Strings (Strawberry) Rock Candy Strings (Strawberry)

    Strawberry flavored rock candy is an old time favorite. This rock candy comes on a string and is perfect for eating.

    $6.99/lb
  • Grape Candy Sticks Grape Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These grape candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Cherry Candy Sticks Cherry Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These cherry candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Double Chocolate Caramel Creams Double Chocolate Caramel Creams

    Goetze's double chocolate caramel creams are chocolate caramel with a creamy chocolate center.

    $5.99/lb
  • Lime Candy Sticks Lime Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These lime candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Rootbeer Candy Sticks Rootbeer Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These rootbeer candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Tutti Fruitti Candy Sticks Tutti Fruitti Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These tutti fruitti candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Vanilla Turkish Taffy Vanilla Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Vanilla Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99
  • Watermelon Candy Sticks Watermelon Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These watermelon candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Yellow Whirly Pop (3 Inches) Yellow Whirly Pop (3 Inches)

    Yellow and white whirly pops are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These classic old time lollipops are a real treat. 1.5 ounces and 3" diameter.

    $4.99
  • Butterscotch Candy Sticks Butterscotch Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These butterscotch candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Clove Candy Sticks Clove Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These clove candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Banana Turkish Taffy Banana Turkish Taffy

    Enjoy a true blast from another era with Bonomo's Banana Turkish Taffy.

    $7.99
  • Rainbow Whirly Pop (6.5 inches) Rainbow Whirly Pop (6.5 inches)

    Rainbow whirly pops are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These huge and classic old time lollipops are a real treat. 10 ounces and 6.5" diameter.

    $7.99
  • Brown Rock Candy Sticks (Unwrapped) Brown Rock Candy Sticks (Unwrapped)

    This classic root beer flavored rock candy comes in a package of 10 units on a stick. The sticks measure approximately 6 1/2 inches, and the rock candy measures approximately 4 inches. Great for wedding favors, candy buffets, or just to eat!

    $8.99
  • Jelly Belly Jewel Very Cherry Jelly Belly Jewel Very Cherry

    These Jelly Belly jelly beans have a traditional cherry flavor with a unique and beautiful dark pink shimmer coating. Make these a part of your candy buffet to impress guests.

    $8.99/lb
  • Mega Candy Buttons Mega Candy Buttons

    Everyone loves candy buttons. We promise you will love these mega candy button. HUGE candy buttons like you have never seen will surely please the kid in all of us.

    $3.99
  • Raspberry Candy Sticks Raspberry Candy Sticks

    These nostalgic old time candy sticks bring back great memories. These raspberry candy sticks taste great. Perfect for snacking, candy buffets, or wedding.

    $3.99
  • Unicorn Pops (10 inches) Unicorn Pops (10 inches)

    These massive rainbow Unicorn Pops are are famous from amusement parks, carnivals, and boardwalks. These classic old time lollipops are a real treat.

    $5.99
  • World's Biggest Candy Necklace World's Biggest Candy Necklace

    There is a normal candy necklace then there is the World's Biggest Candy Necklace. We aren't kidding either! You will be amazed at just how big and delicious this is.

    $4.49

Narrow by tag

more…

Sign up for our newsletter

Receive limited, email-only offers

Jeffrey's Picks

Samples

Samples

Want to try a smaller size before indulging big time? Check out our tasty samples! $2.50 a sample.